![]() |
created with Ideogram AI and Adobe Photoshop |
Since 2020, I've regularly participated in online master classes through either Sniffapalooza or Beautyhabit and until recently had never sniffed any of the samples in advance. I wanted to write about Nicolai Parfumeur Createur's Parfum Gourmand collection for the blog, so I thought that this one time I'd have an advance sniff. Besides, it's much easier to take notes and really concentrate on the fragrances without someone speaking in the background (though I've had to listen to my bigmouth neighbor talk most of the day; our walls are like paper).
When I write about a fragrance, I start the process by going to Fragrantica and pulling up the notes for each scent before scrolling down to read the comments. There is usually a mix of opinions from members who are snobs, noobs, bros, and wanna-bes, plus a handful of folks who genuinely have a good sense of smell and tell it like it is. Since these three scents are allegedly gourmands, I figured that they'd have a good number of positive comments. People like gourmands, particularly well-crafted ones, so I was unprepared for the negativity around these perfumes. Some comments made Macaron Bourbon and Pavlova seem downright scary.
"Synthetic, obnoxious, loud, disgusting, and just cruel to the nose.""How can a 'Macaron' fragrance be so terrible!?? SCRUBBER!!!""Overly sweet synthetic mess. NO""It really smells like something I got in the summer from Bath and Body Works.""There is a special place in hell and in my trash can for this sample."
Wow, don't hold back. Tell us what you really think. Thankfully, these fragrances weren't as terrible as these comments might suggest.
Based on the notes alone, I figured I'd like Saint Honoré the most, followed by Pavlova and Macaron Bourbon. Pavlova did indeed come in second place, but the other two switched places. Sadly, I really hated Saint Honoré. Read on for more.
Rum, Bitter Almond, Davana, Rose, Cinnamon, Clove, Patchouli, Caramel, Vanilla, Tonka Bean, Musk
As I've learned from the Great British Bake Off, one should use the barest drop of rose essence in baking, otherwise the end result could taste like soap. While Macaron Bourbon doesn't smell like soap, it does smell like too much rose. But then, I am often on the fence about rose notes. I'm assuming that this fragrance is supposed to evoke a rose-flavored macaron, perhaps one with a spicy caramel filling, but it does not. I would say this was a rose fragrance, not a gourmand fragrance, though it is sweet. The rose note is too much like the actual flower with a touch of green and thorns. I think a softer, rosewater-like, note would have hit the confection mark more accurately. In any case, I am mostly quibbling with the name of the scent compared to the way it actually smells. This perfume, taken on its own, is fine: a pretty rose scent with a sweet vanilla drydown. It's not in any way horrifying, as the Fragrantica reviewers would like us to believe, but it's not my cup of tea.
Pavlova Intense
Pineapple, Passionfruit, Rum, Peach, Coconut, Raspberry, Vanilla, Musk, Sandalwood, Cedar
This one is not scary, either. I've never had a pavlova with tropical fruits, but I'm sure it would be delicious. This Pavlova is light and airy, like meringue. The fruit notes are nice, with the pineapple and passionfruit coming out first, and eventually the raspberry. Overall, though, it's giving Fruit Stripe gum (do they still make that?) or very sweet shampoo. This fragrance is quite youthful, though not as sweet as half the stuff marketed toward young people. Sadly, the drydown is not particularly interesting on paper. I tried it on my skin but found that the fruits aren't as distinct and the scent is otherwise rather generic. Too bad, because I actually did sorta like this one.
Saint Honoré Intense
Pepper, Bergamot, Hazelnut, Milk, Orange Blossom, Vanilla Absolute, Sandalwood, Amber, Musk
I saved the best for last, or so I thought. The list of notes makes it sound perfect for me; this scent also received the most positive comments. But it was hate at first sniff. I don't know if it's the pepper or the hazelnut, or a combination of everything that makes Saint Honoré smell like root beer. But that's on paper. I couldn't believe this wasn't going to be delicious on skin, so I sprayed some on the back of my hand. The hazelnut note comes out right away; it's buttery and nutty and delicious and lasts about 15 seconds. And then it's root beer. Oh, and I do not like root beer, which makes this a scrubber for me.
-----------------------
Posted by theminx on Minxstinks
Note: this post is my opinion. I am not affiliated with the companies mentioned in this post or any other companies.
-----------------------
Posted by theminx on Minxstinks
Note: this post is my opinion. I am not affiliated with the companies mentioned in this post or any other companies.